Gov. Desantis Suspends Four Broward County School Board Members

The Governor’s Office appointed replacements for School Board members Patricia Good, Donna Korn, Ann Murray and Laurie Rich Levinson, immediately suspending them for “incompetence, neglect of duty and misuse of authority” relating to mismanaging an $800 million low-cost construction bond.

“These are inexcusable actions by School Board members who have shown a pattern of emboldening unacceptable behavior, including fraud and mismanagement, across the district,” a news release from the Governor’s Office read.

One of the four, Korn, was heading to a runoff election, as she was the top vote-getter in Tuesday’s Primary Election. She garnered 30.5% of the vote, with her closest competitor, candidate Allen Zeman, earning 29.9%.

A fifth Board member that the grand jury recommended for removal, Sen. Rosalind Osgood, resigned from the Board to run for election in Senate District 35, thus falling outside the Governor’s authority, the release says.

The Board members have the opportunity to appeal the suspension with the Senate, but Murray and Rich Levinson are out of office in November, as they opted to not seek re-election. Good’s term runs to 2024. So Good, Korn, Murray and Rich Levinson will be replaced by the Governor’s appointees, at least for the time being. The appointees are:

— Torey Alston, a businessman the Governor appointed to the Broward County Commission to fill the unexpired term of Commissioner Dale Holness, who resigned to run for Congress.

— Manual “Nandy” A. Serrano, a member of the Florida Sports Foundation Board of Directors, and CEO and founder of Clubhouse Private Wealth.

— Ryan Reiter, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran and Director of Government Relations for Kaufman Lynn Construction.

— Kevin Tynan, a lawyer with Richardson and Tynan, who previously served on the Broward County School Board and South Broward Hospital District.

The order does not say which person will take which seat until the two new Board members are seated next month, who will fill out Good’s term that runs until 2024, or what happens with Korn’s runoff election. Florida Politics’ inquiry to the Governor’s Office was not immediately returned.

The appointments will increase the number of male board members currently from one to five.

DeSantis in 2019 impaneled a grand jury in response to the Parkland massacre, the state’s worst school shooting that left 17 people dead and another 17 people injured.

The grand jury’s investigation expanded far beyond an inquiry into the shooting, however. The grand jury also put the Broward County School Board and its processes under a microscope after the Sun-Sentinel identified corruption and mismanagement relating to technology purchases and the construction bond.

The report was completed in April 2021 and has already resulted in criminal charges, according to the Sun-Sentinel. The district’s former Superintendent Robert Runcie resigned and was indicted for perjury. General Counsel Barbara Myrick also was arrested for charges related to perjury before the grand jury. And earlier, Tony Hunter, the district’s former chief information officer, was arrested for bid rigging and bribery charges to which he has pleaded not guilty.

The Governor’s order notes that the board was not responsible for their criminal actions, but were not entirely blameless for what happened.

“The permissive atmosphere the Board created for its former employees, coupled with the board unwillingness to hold Runcie, Myrick and other employees accountable, emboldened their unacceptable behavior,” the order reads.

The grand jury’s complete report was not released until last week to give those named in it an opportunity to respond.

Osgood told Florida Politics last week, when the grand jury report came out, that she did not neglect her duty as the grand jury report said. She was the Chair of the Board when she stepped down.

“I didn’t neglect my duties,” she said. “I showed up and I worked hard every time, every day for the kids in this community.”

The Governor’s order notes that the grand jury’s final report found that a safety-related fire alarm at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School that could have saved lives during the shooting was part of the delayed improvements.

Friday’s order attached the grand jury report that slammed the Board’s ability to hold district administrators accountable. It said the Board would chide the Superintendent for failing to advance building projects, only to rate him as “effective” or “highly effective.”

“The result in paralysis has created a knock-on effect, costing the taxpayers of Broward County millions of extra dollars as projects fall literal years behind schedule and students continue to be educated in decrepit, moldy, unsafe buildings.”